Palantir may be out, but another firm co-founded by its former employees is in
Even as government says Palantir’s NHS contract will end in 2029, it has signed a £10.8 million deal with ElevenLabs, a company co-founded by former Palantir employees
Welcome back to The Eye - our weekly guide to the shifting relationship between Big Tech and the state.
This week: Palantir’s uncertain exit, another lucrative deal for US Big Tech, and the question of Britain’s digital sovereignty.
The UK government has recently signed a new £10.8 million contract with ElevenLabs, co-founded by an ex-Palantir strategist and a Google machine learner.
While the firm was founded in and holds a primary European headquarters in London, tax documents reflect that it is ultimately controlled by a parent company, Eleven Labs Inc, ‘registered and incorporated in the United States,’ also holding offices in New York, as well as in San Francisco. The company was founded in 2022, later opening its London office in 2024 according to its website, which refers to London as ‘the perfect place for our next phase of growth’.
The new deal is to supply a cross-government AI voice platform to automate public enquiries across central government departments. Its stated aim is to “reduce wait times, improve accessibility, and provide quicker resolutions for common queries,” and follows on from a research agreement dating back to February, with the then-Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) and its AI Security Institute.
The contract also provides for “exit and transition assistance” under Clause 25 and Schedule 1. But the entire schedule is redacted, leaving the public unable to see what the government could rely on if it needed to change suppliers or how a potential handover would work.
There is no wrongdoing implied on behalf of ElevenLabs, or any corporate link between ElevenLabs and Palantir itself - but the deal raises wider questions about overdependence on ultimately US-controlled tech companies with no transparent scenario-planning for the future.
Recent reporting on AI drone manufacturer Anduril - again staffed by former Palantir employees - has exposed its lobbying blitz on this side of the Atlantic. The company has now secured over £50m in government contracts, and as reported by Byline Times, has deep ties to Peter Thiel and the Trump administration.
An end date but no guarantee of exit
Fears about continued US over-influence and dominance in the UK market come after Parliamentary Under-Secretary for the Department of Health and Social Care James Frith finally addressed the issue of Palantir’s continued role in the NHS on 16 November, following reports that the company was to be granted a two-year extension.
Speaking to Parliament, Frith said that he “can confirm that the contract will end in March 2029”, prompting a degree of optimism from campaign organisations, including the Citizens, which has been calling for the NHS contract to be terminated for years.
However, there may yet be no lasting cause for celebration, as Frith added that “the next iteration of the FDP [would include] all possible suppliers”, crucially, “both international and [from the] UK, through an open and transparent procurement process”. This presumably means that Palantir would be free to bid once more to retain its contract. Frith also confirmed that until the contract ends, Palantir will be paid at the same rate it currently is for the FDP.
March 2029 is a long time away, and a lot could happen within that time. An early general election could be called and plans to exit the contract could be scrapped under a change of government. It therefore remains to be seen how effectively the British state will untangle itself from Palantir and what the future iteration of the FDP will actually look like.
In a statement to Politico, which called the announcement a ‘two year reprieve’ for the company, a spokesperson for Palantir said the government’s position was “good news” and that Palantir would “redouble our efforts over the next two years to continue and accelerate” support in the NHS as well as deepening “our investment in the UK”.
Speaking during the parliamentary debate, Labour MP Dame Chi Onwurah - chair of the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee - said she was “extremely disappointed” at Palantir being granted the two-year extension, highlighting potential vendor lock-in to the US company as a problem, despite reassurances from Frith that no such lock-in exists. Making her statement, Onwurah said that “if a break clause cannot be exercised because of continuity of care, it is not a break clause, it is a lock-in”.
One MP called Palantir an “albatross” that was “hanging around the NHS’s neck”, and Liberal Democrat spokesperson Helen Morgan also spoke in no uncertain terms, reiterating calls for “digital sovereignty in the NHS”. She said that the Lib Dems were clear that “we need to get Palantir out of the NHS, a Trump-aligned tech giant should be nowhere near the data of millions of patients, and a piece of important national infrastructure”.
As well as the opacity surrounding the procurement process of the FDP deal, Morgan also outlined the “national security implications of offshoring the whole of our nation’s health data to a company with an appalling human rights record, run by an ally of Donald Trump”. As reported last Friday, The Nerve also outlined nine key reasons why the NHS needs to ditch Palantir’s FDP contract, including vendor lock-in.
The NHS FDP has shown why these details matter: the lack of a clear exit plan and the failure to identify alternative suppliers early enough have made it harder to prepare for a transition away from Palantir. Why, then, are the exit arrangements in contracts for companies like ElevenLabs (whether US-controlled or not) being kept from public view?
The risks of reliance
The wider debate here is about more than Palantir, its ties to the US security apparatus and the Trump administration, or any single tech company. It raises a more basic question - what does digital sovereignty mean in practice? Palantir certainly has its own take on the term. While the government says the next FDP procurement will be open to international suppliers, that leaves the meaning of what constitutes truly ‘sovereign’ technology still unclear.
The recent and catastrophic global outage of Microsoft services, which spanned two workdays, once again underlines the drastic need for the UK to cease reliance on a handful of Silicon Valley mega-corporations.The outage, which downed critical services causing disruptions across multiple industries, affecting schools, businesses, governments, police forces and health providers, has now been pinned on “three factors”, which reportedly combined created a perfect storm for the failure.
Microsoft is not an isolated incident. It coincides with mounting concern about the UK’s over-reliance on US-owned tech. A new report from People Vs Big Tech reveals that 84 out of 100 of the UK’s most critical firms are at risk from an over-reliance on US tech firms. Organisations including the perpetually beleaguered Thames Water, Royal Mail, much of the NHS, and the entire electricity transmission network in England and Wales rely on US technology to operate.
The report highlights that if the US were to ever cut off access to Microsoft, Google, and others, possibly through sanctions or an Executive Order, 95 percent of the 100 key organisations identified would be vulnerable to serious breakdowns in operability, with just five of those services identified not reliant on American firms.
As previously reported by the Citizens, while other European countries are moving away from dependence on an unreliable and unpredictable supposed ally, the UK, despite its overtures to “sovereignty”, is falling far behind other nations in becoming truly independent, to the point that the Open Rights Group, in a detailed report on digital sovereignty, has called the UK’s reliance on US infrastructure a threat to national security.
About The Eye: In an era where Silicon Valley is rewriting the rules of governance and unaccountable tech companies are capturing our public services from the inside out, The Eye exists to follow the power, connect the dots and reveal how technology is reshaping our state.